The International Cricket Council (ICC) has dismissed Pakistan Cricket Board’s (PCB) demand to remove match referee Andy Pycroft from the ongoing Asia Cup 2025 panel. The 69-year-old Zimbabwean official is scheduled to oversee Pakistan’s final group stage clash against the United Arab Emirates on September 17.
Background of the Controversy
The dispute emerged after Pakistan’s high-voltage encounter against India, where a post-match controversy sparked headlines. Following the intense game, reports surfaced that Indian players did not participate in the customary handshake with Pakistani cricketers. The PCB held Pycroft responsible, accusing him of mishandling the matter and subsequently demanded his removal.
The incident, dubbed as the “no handshake furore,” added fuel to the already heated cricketing rivalry between India and Pakistan, with emotions spilling beyond the field.
PCB’s Strong Reaction
According to sources, the PCB not only filed a formal complaint but also issued veiled threats of withdrawing from the tournament if Pycroft continued to officiate their matches. The board argued that the referee’s oversight undermined the spirit of the game and unfairly impacted Pakistan’s image on the international stage.
ICC’s Response
The ICC, however, stood firmly by Pycroft. In its statement on Tuesday, September 16, 2025, the global cricket body emphasized that all match officials are appointed on merit and experience. It stressed that personal grievances or disagreements cannot dictate officiating appointments during a prestigious multi-nation tournament like the Asia Cup.
The ICC’s rejection highlights its stance on maintaining independence of officiating staff, resisting external pressure from member boards, and ensuring fairness in decision-making.
About Andy Pycroft
Andy Pycroft, a former Zimbabwe cricketer, has been part of the ICC’s Elite Panel of Match Referees for years. Known for his vast experience, he has officiated in numerous high-profile international games. Despite PCB’s criticism, he enjoys the ICC’s confidence as a neutral and respected figure in cricket administration.
What Lies Ahead
Pakistan is now left with two choices—either to continue competing under Pycroft’s supervision or risk a damaging pullout that could affect its relationship with both the ICC and the Asian Cricket Council (ACC). With Pakistan eyeing a semi-final berth, the cricketing world is watching closely to see whether the board prioritizes its protest or its performance on the field.
The Asia Cup has often been a stage for drama both on and off the pitch, but this controversy may test the limits of PCB’s diplomacy with the game’s governing body.
